Skip to content

Longford Lecture Wasting time – missed opportunities to change lives

Thank you, Peter, it’s a huge honour to be invited to give this lecture, and wonderful to see so many people here tonight.

 And can I begin by paying tribute to the work of the Longford Trust – it is an outstanding organisation that helps to transform the lives of its scholars?  

Also, can I say good evening to those prisoners out there listening on national prison radio or watching us on Way Out TV? I hope this talk is interesting to you as well.

I would also like to pay tribute to our people at the Inspectorate of Prisons – it has been one of the great privileges of my life to work with such a brilliant and dedicated team. And even though things have been pretty grim at times, we can point to many prisons such as Exeter, Chelmsford, Bedford and Lowdham Grange that have turned around and improved after very poor inspections.

The hardest thing about writing this lecture has been the many things that I would liked to have talked about, but in half an hour, I simply won’t have the time. So, I’m sorry, I won’t, in any detail, talk about children in custody, the importance good staff/prisoner relationships, the welcome government announcement on those imprisoned for public protection, the astonishing numbers of ex-prisoners who are recalled to custody, the early release scheme, the infrastructure of prisons, overcrowding, and the constant problems nationally with recruiting and retaining prison officers.

Ever since I began visiting prisons in 2015, I was struck, but not surprised, by the similarities between some of the children who came to the special school that I used to run, and those who ended up in custody.

The stories of their lives mirrored those of many of my pupils – who were brought up in homes that were unstable and sometimes abusive, and where misuse of drugs and alcohol, criminality, family breakdown, mental health difficulties and domestic violence were common.

And while, in most cases, by providing support for these children and their families, we could get them back on track, a few sadly became involved in crime.

I have a photograph of one such child at home. In the picture, Travis, is eleven-years-old, and he is performing in the year 6 leavers’ concert. His best friend was due to sing a solo, but had just had an attack of stage fright, and had dried up.

Travis stepped in, and began the solo himself, fading out, only when his friend found his voice. In the picture, he stands with his arms out, joy on his face, while in the background one of the teachers can be seen wiping her eyes with a handkerchief.

Travis went on to be sentenced to 10 years for grievous bodily harm.

And when I walk around a jail, I imagine what the prisoners I meet looked like when they were still at primary school and what sequence of events and choices led them to end up in prison.

I want to talk tonight about what prison is like for people like Travis, I will focus on three main areas, drugs, the way in which prisoners spend their time and also, prison leadership. And as well as highlighting the many problems, I want to show how I think things can be improved.

I will compare the realities of life inside, with the commonly stated aims of prison. To deter, to punish, to protect the public and to rehabilitate and I will show that in many jails we are failing in each one of these areas.

Without doubt, the biggest challenge facing prisons in 2026 is the amount of illegal drugs that are pouring in, feeding addiction and criminality. Around a quarter of men and nearly half the women who go to jail admit having a problem with drugs or alcohol, and that means there is a huge, literally captive, market for criminals to exploit.

In the past, the usual ways to get contraband into prisons was to throw small packages over the wall, sneak stuff through visits, or try to corrupt staff. But all that has now changed because, with increasingly sophisticated technology, and in a matter of seconds, drones can deliver packages that weigh more 10 kilogrammes, to an individual cell.

The worst-hit jail is HMP Hindley just outside Wigan, where we inspected just a couple of weeks ago. In random testing of prisoners, over 50% were coming back positive for drugs. That’s 50% of men actively involved in criminality while they are supposed to be in the care of the state.

And in the most exposed jails, prisoners can now order drugs off a menu, including cannabis, ketamine, cocaine and heroin. There is even availability of lifestyle drugs – such as Minoxidil for hair loss, Ozempic for weight loss and anabolic steroids for body building – so if prisoners want to look good on the wing.

The mark-up on this stuff is enormous with criminals making astonishing amounts of money. And remember, in the main, it’s not prisoners who are paying – there’s no cash in prisons. Drug debts are paid by family members through bank transfer.

And we have no idea of the scale of this problem– the extent to which grandparents are forced to go to the building society and draw out their life savings, to stop their grandson from being beaten up.

Because that’s how it works in prison, if you don’t pay your debts, you’ll be assaulted. The drug market is the main reason for increases in violence in recent years, reaching astonishingly high levels in many jails.

Meanwhile, the response to the drone threat from successive governments, the prison service, the Ministry of Justice, the Home Office, the police, the Ministry of Defence and the security services has been embarrassingly slow. There has been a failure to share information or develop a coherent strategy to tackle this national challenge.

This means that rather than being a respite from the drugs and the dealers on the streets, things in prisons are often even worse.

Organised crime bosses are not being punished, they’re certainly not being deterred or rehabilitated and the public are not being protected, while these men continue to run their operations in the community from their prison cells. Jails know who these individuals are, and yet they can operate with impunity.

We have special units for the most violent men, or for those who seek to radicalise their peers.  And I am now convinced that we must manage organised crime bosses more assertively while they are in prison. We should be following prisons in France, Italy and Holland where these men are now housed in special protected units. They cannot be allowed to continue to make money, while they prey on vulnerable people inside and outside of prison.

But we won’t solve the drug problem with security measures alone. It is compounded because of a lack of proper support for the many men and women with addiction problems. People who are caught in a vicious cycle of homelessness, mental health difficulties, drug taking, criminality and prison.

The desperation amongst these people was brought home to me when we inspected Bedford prison in 2023. The jail was in a terrible state – filthy, violent, rat infested, overcrowded and in the segregation unit, when it rained, staff had to wear wellington boots because raw sewage came up through the floor. Men were so bored that two we came across were racing cockroaches to pass the time. But walking around one the wings, I randomly unlocked a cell and introduced myself to a prisoner in his mid-twenties called Leo.

We chatted about his life and how he had ended up in trouble, and during the conversation, to my amazement, he told me he saw Bedford prison as the closest he ever got to feeling at home. He was addicted to heroin, lived homeless on the street and if he couldn’t beg enough money to buy drugs, then he would go out thieving. And he told me he was regularly assaulted because he was in debt to drug dealers.

“Here” he said, “the officers look after me, I sleep in a bed, I get a shower, eat three meals a day and I’m given my daily dose of methadone.”

It was astonishing to hear. I was about to write one of the worst reports I had ever written about a prison, but Leo was describing it as a haven.

And this wasn’t an isolated incident. Another time I was watching prisoners being released from HMP Styal, a women’s prison in Cheshire, and the officer on duty offered to get a prisoner’s property out of storage for her to take away. But she knew she would be sleeping rough that night and she said,

“Don’t bother, it’s safer leaving it here, and anyway I’ll be back soon.”

And when we were inspecting the cells at Birkenhead court, I sat in on a case where a man, who was up for a string of shoplifting offences begged the magistrates to send him to prison, so that he’d have somewhere warm to sleep over Christmas.

Ultimately, if we want to reduce the prison population, we will have to do something for these women and these men.

Of those we have data on, as many as a quarter leave prisons like Wormwood Scrubs or Bronzefied street homeless. Without the availability of safe, settled accommodation, it is impossible to see the staggeringly high prison population reduce.

In our prisoner surveys, astonishingly, 15% of men and 18% of women say they have developed a drug or alcohol problem while they have been in in prison.

No wonder, former Home Secretary, Douglas Hurd described prison as “an expensive way of making bad people worse.”

And it is expensive – it now costs a staggering £57 thousand pounds a year to keep someone behind bars. In other words, it costs about much to go to Winchester prison as it does to go to Winchester College.

A few years ago, the prison service introduced a half-hearted attempt at developing drug free wings, known as incentivised substance-free living units. Unfortunately, many are neither incentivised nor drug free. Indeed, one prisoner told me it was the best place in the jail to buy drugs. The staff have often had no training and know little or nothing about the process of recovery.

Sometimes, it is hard to find a prisoner on these ‘drug-free wings’ who actually has a drug problem, because they have been taken over by organised crime gang members, with designer trainers and expensively whitened teeth, who have got themselves onto these units, to escape the chaos they have created elsewhere in the jail.

Despite that, there is some really impressive drug recovery work going on. During her tenure at both Cardiff and Bristol, the outstanding governor, Amanda Corrigan set up drug free units. Here, there is an extensive recovery programme with prisoner- run alcoholics and narcotics anonymous groups, and support from well-trained staff.

Prisoners talk about their lives being transformed. One man told me he had been clean for the first time in more than ten years, most of which he had spent in prison.

Other jails such as the Mount, Featherstone and Aylesbury are also making real progress with drug recovery. But elsewhere there is a very long way to go – as part of our fieldwork for a report on drugs, that we will produce next year, we interviewed drug users who were leaving prison, a few months later, a worryingly large number are already back inside again.

So, I want to talk now about how prisoners spend their time. Since the founding of the inspectorate in its current form in 1982, every chief inspector has commented on the lack of purposeful activity in most jails. But now it is worse than ever.

Only in a handful of prisons, are there enough spaces for every prisoner to be involved in work, training or education. And in so many of the jails I’ve inspected we find men and women locked behind their doors for up to 22 hours a day, with nothing to give them any sense of purpose, or the skills that they need to get work on release, and stop the cycle of crime and reoffending.

Standards of education are almost universally poor with our colleagues at Ofsted rarely awarding anything but their lowest scores to the prisons we jointly inspect. And last year there were significant cuts to prison education with some jails losing more than 50% of their education hours. And anyway, sessions are regularly cancelled, because there aren’t enough prison officers available to escort men or women to the education block.

Although there are a few prisons, such as Chelmsford or Frankland that have made reading integral to the day-to-day operations of the prison, in many jails, and there is little or no help for the 50% of prisoners who are functionally illiterate. The most depressing finding in our 2022 review of the teaching of reading was that those with the most need, got the least help. Thank goodness, for organisations like the Longford Trust, Peter.

Even prisoners who do have work are often woefully underemployed. Huge numbers have jobs as full-time wing cleaners, who can do their day’s work in just a couple of hours. For the rest of the day, they loaf about on the landing chatting to their fellows and vaping.

Those who do go off the wing to workshops often depart late – and, assuming work hasn’t been cancelled, are back in cells for a two-hour lunchbreak by midday. Many jails do not run education or training at all on a Friday and most prisons are pretty much shut down at the weekends.

None of this is any preparation for work on the outside and just a handful of jails have prisoners involved in all-day working.

So, what do these prisoners do all day?

Well, the answer for a large proportion, is that they lie on their beds, watching daytime television and taking drugs. And in many cases, this is probably exactly how they spend their time at home.

But despite this depressing picture, there are some outstanding prisons that do transform the lives of the people they lock up.

Rehabilitation is a nebulous concept, that’s hard to define, but you kind of know it when you see it.

The best prison in the country is HMP Oakwood outside Wolverhampton.

At the heart of Oakwood’s success are the many prisoner-led initiatives – these are schemes generated and led by the men to help their fellow inmates. One prisoner, doing a life sentence, set up a woodwork shop to support some of the most vulnerable men.

Nearby, in a polytunnel, three prisoners proudly showed me the vegetables and herbs they were growing. Anywhere else, there would have been staff closely supervising them, but at Oakwood they worked alone.

The last time I was there, I came across a guy from the military who had got himself in trouble, who was meeting his German shepherd for the first time in two years. because the prison was allowing well-behaved dogs to visit the best-behaved prisoners. With this sort of incentive, that man will not be breaking the prison’s rules.

Trust is at the heart of the success at Oakwood. Prisoners are given opportunities and freedoms that would frighten staff in other jails. Everyone is expected to be in work or education every day, and there are many incentives for doing the right thing. But those who break the rules are robustly dealt with. And there is no sense that the prison is soft, with expectations on prisoners universally high. Risk is carefully managed and before prisoners earn these privileges, they have to show that they can be trusted.

There’s even a specialist wing for men who have got into trouble at the jail, where they are supported by a group of highly motivated peers to behave well, get work and move back into the main part of the jail.

In most prisons we inspect, prisoners surround inspectors to tell them all the many problems at the jail. At Oakwood, they accost you to tell you what a good prison it is.

As John McCloughlin, the inspirational former governor at Oakwood said to me – “show me the crime and I’ll be as shocked as anyone, but show me the man and I’ll walk with him.”

It is true, Oakwood has the advantage of being a modern jail, that was only opened in 2012, and as the largest prison in the country – holding more than 2,000 men – it has some economies of scale. But not only is it the best prison in the country, it is, at £29 thousand pounds per prisoner, per year, one of the cheapest. It is also privately run by G4S.

Data from our inspections since the end of the pandemic show that male, private prisons – that is, jails contracted out by the Ministry of Justice by competitive tender, consistently outperform those in the public sector. Of course, they have some advantages – many are in newer buildings where living conditions are generally better – and I don’t underestimate the effect that has on prisoner and staff morale.

But better buildings and living conditions don’t account for the fact that we often find that prisoners in private jails are safer, better occupied and more effectively prepared for release.

Now I understand that some of you might not like the idea of private prisons and feel squeamish about shareholders making money out of incarceration.

And I want to be clear – at the inspectorate we don’t take a view on privatisation, and we have certainly seen some privately run prisons get into terrible difficulties.

But it’s worth asking why is it that many of the best, most innovative, most rehabilitative prisons are in the private sector?

The answer, I think lies in leadership. And I am not, for a moment, saying that governors in the private sector are better – some of the best prison leaders in the country – David Redhouse, Jenifer Willis and Mick Mlls – all run public sector jails. The problem is the system that surrounds them. In the inspectorate we have always known that the best governors can transform outcomes, even in some of the most troubled places.

And having done this job for 6 years, I am in awe of prison governors. In my long career, they are, without doubt, the most impressive public servants with whom I have ever worked.

And yet too often, the centralised bureaucracy constrains the system it is supposed to support. It turns out, for example, that governors are not allowed to spend more than £500 on an individual item unless they go through a protracted procurement exercise.

So, if a washing machine breaks on the wing, governors have a choice – buy a domestic replacement for less than £500 which, with the amount of use it gets, will probably break down in a matter of months, or go through a ministry of Justice procurement process that could take months.

One governor in an open prison told me he needed some office windows fixed, so he got a quote from a local glazier for £14k, but he was told that he had to go through a central procurement process. This resulted in the work being awarded to a contractor who charged £47k. That contractor, went and sub-let the work to, guess who? The original glazier. And this kind of thing happens all the time and it’s a scandal.

These rules also mean that governors can’t commission basic works.

Lincoln prison has been relying on temporary boilers, hired at huge annual cost for the last 9 years, the jail has spent far more than it would have, had the work been done properly in the first place.

But it isn’t just the money, it’s people too.

I was horrified when I discovered that public sector governors do not recruit their own prison officers. This is done by a central team, who do not even conduct a face-to-face interview. The idea that I, as a headteacher, would employ someone in my school without interviewing them would be unthinkable.

Yet for governors, the first time they meet new staff, is the first day they walk into the jail. And prison leaders tell me that within seconds they can tell, that a proportion of these new officers are not up to the job. It is important to say that most prison officers are brilliant people, doing a difficult job in what is often a very challenging environment.

But if a governor wants to get rid of an officer who is not good enough, the process is interminable. Even those caught bringing drugs or other contraband into prisons, can get suspended on full pay for many months, at the taxpayers’ expense, before they can be fired.

But it gets worse – a governor recently told me that he had finally managed to sack a prison officer, who some months later, came back into his prison, re-recruited by the prison service’s central team.

And this is the big problem, responsibility and accountability are in different places – prison governors are held responsible for the quality of their prison, not least by the inspectorate of prisons, but they don’t get to choose who works there.

I am still amazed that people who are caring for more than 1k prisoners and 400 staff, who have a budget or £25M, whose phone rings at the weekend to say there has been a disturbance or a death – are still not trusted to spend money wisely. It’s absurd.

And they get paid less than the head teacher in your local secondary school.

In private prisons, the opposite is often the case, governors are granted high levels of autonomy, and they are held to account for their performance. They must deliver against the contract their organisation has signed otherwise the company will attract fines that can run into the millions.

If governors in private jails mess up, ultimately, they can be sacked. But they are also, and this is crucial, given the tools to do the job. They have control over their budgets, can decide how to spend money, and who to employ and they are not constrained by the iron grip of the prison service.

The evidence here is very clear – if you want an effective service – any service – empower leaders to do their job and hold them to account for how they do it.

So look, I’ve been knocking around this world for six years now. And I still absolutely believe in the possibility of rehabilitation – but I am not shiny-eyed and naïve. There are many people in prison who are in definitely in the right place, and some of them should be there for a very long time.

But politicians are unable to resist the temptation to sound tough and increase prison sentences – but for what?

In a year’s time, prisons will be close to filling up again, despite all the early release schemes. And by the autumn of 2028, projections suggest, we are looking at another full-on prison, population crisis.

And given that we can’t recruit enough officers to run our existing prisons, how on earth will we be able to staff all these new jails?

We need a prison service that reorients itself towards rehabilitation – helping prisoners to recover from addiction and giving them the skills and the training to go out to work successfully on release. We should actively and assertively disrupt organised crime gangs. And we need to trust our governors to run their jails, allow them to hire and fire their own staff, and do everything to reduce their bureaucratic burden, so they can get on with job.

Ultimately, you can mandate mediocracy, but to unleash excellence, you have to set leaders free.

But if we think we can just keep building more prisons, that don’t have enough staff, leaving people like Travis locked in their cells for hours on end, if we can’t keep drugs out of prison and help prisoners to deal with their addiction, if we can’t prepare them for a successful life on the outside, with the skills to get a job, and if we can’t find somewhere decent for them to live.

Then we’re not only wasting time, we’re wasting money and we’re wasting lives.

Thank you.